Let’s break down the idea of putting in a lower offer on a house in detail—especially in the context of the South African property market.
π What Does a Lower Offer Mean?
Making a lower offer means offering to buy the house for less than the seller's asking price. It’s a negotiation strategy and not unusual at all.
✅ When It's Smart to Offer Less
Here are the common situations where a lower offer is both reasonable and expected:
1. The Property Is Overpriced
- Sellers sometimes list properties above market value.
- Compare similar recent sales (called comparative market analysis) to gauge the fair price.
- If the asking price is R1,200,000 but similar homes sell for R1,050,000, you have a strong case to offer lower.
2. The Property Has Been on the Market a Long Time
- If the home has been listed for 3 months or more, the seller may be more open to negotiation.
- A long listing period suggests the price might be too high or there’s little interest.
3. There Are Visible Issues or Repairs Needed
- If the home needs fixing (e.g., roof, plumbing, structural cracks), you can subtract estimated repair costs from your offer.
- Example: House listed at R950,000, needs R100,000 in repairs. You might offer R850,000.
4. The Seller Is Motivated
- Some sellers need to relocate for a job, are going through divorce, or want to sell urgently.
- Estate agents may hint at this. If so, you’re in a strong position to negotiate.
5. It's a Buyer’s Market
- When there are more homes for sale than buyers, sellers may accept lower offers to close the deal.
- Look for signs like price reductions or lots of listings sitting unsold in the area.
⚖️ How Much Lower Can You Go?
There’s no fixed rule, but typically:
- 5–10% below asking price is common and often reasonable.
- More than 10–15% below might only be accepted if the house has problems or the seller is very motivated.
Example:
- Asking price: R1,300,000
- Your offer: R1,170,000 (10% below)
- Justification: Based on market comparisons and minor repairs needed.
π How to Submit a Lower Offer
In South Africa, you submit your offer using an Offer to Purchase (OTP). This is a legal document and should include:
- The price you're offering
- Conditions (e.g., subject to bond approval or property inspection)
- Occupation date and deposit (if applicable)
Usually, your estate agent prepares this and submits it to the seller.
⚠️ What to Watch Out For
- Rejection or Counter-Offer: The seller might reject your offer or come back with a counter (a higher price).
- Offending the Seller: Extremely low offers can sometimes offend sellers and end negotiations—be tactful.
- Losing to Other Buyers: If others are interested, going too low might mean losing the deal.
- Your Financing Must Match: Your bank will only lend based on the valuation of the home, not the asking price—this supports fair offers.
π‘ Tip:
Before you make a lower offer, ask the agent:
“Has the seller had any other offers?”
“How long has the property been listed?”
“Has the price been dropped before?”
These answers will guide how aggressive your offer should be.
Would you like an example of a written offer or how to justify a lower offer to the agent or seller?